Cambridge Lower Secondary CheckpointStage 7

Thinking and Working Scientifically: Carrying out scientific enquiry

Science Stage 7 Chapter Notes

What this chapter covers

Thinking and Working Scientifically: Carrying out scientific enquiry
ShareWhatsAppPost
Thinking and Working Scientifically: Carrying out scientific enquiry notes

Unable to load PDF

The notes viewer could not load. Please refresh the page.

Read online free. Download a watermarked copy with a free account.

Read the notes

The full Thinking and Working Scientifically: Carrying out scientific enquiry notes as text: skim, search, and jump between subtopics.

~13 min read

1. Planning: Hypotheses and Variables

The first step in any scientific enquiry is planning. This starts with a hypothesis: a testable statement that proposes an explanation for an observation. For example, 'The rate of photosynthesis increases with light intensity'. From this, you can make a specific prediction for your experiment, like 'If I move the lamp closer to the pondweed, the plant will produce more bubbles of oxygen per minute'. To test this, you must identify your variables. The Independent Variable (IV) is the one thing you change (light intensity). The Dependent Variable (DV) is the thing you measure to see the effect of the change (number of bubbles per minute). All other factors that could affect the outcome, called Control Variables, must be kept the same to ensure a fair test (e.g., temperature, carbon dioxide concentration, type of plant).

Key term

Hypothesis: A proposed explanation for an observation, which can be tested through scientific investigation.

Examiner insight

Examiners look for a clear statement of the independent and dependent variables, and a list of key control variables that would significantly affect the results if not kept constant.

Common pitfall

Confusing a prediction (what you think will happen in a specific experiment) with a hypothesis (the underlying scientific explanation).

Worked example 14 marks

A student wants to investigate the effect of the concentration of acid on the time it takes for a piece of magnesium to react completely. State the independent, dependent, and two control variables for this investigation.

  1. 1

    Independent Variable: The factor that is changed by the scientist. Here, it is the concentration of the acid.

  2. 2

    Dependent Variable: The factor that is measured to observe the effect of the change. Here, it is the time taken for the magnesium to react completely.

  3. 3

    Control Variable 1: A factor kept constant to ensure a fair test. The volume of the acid must be the same for each trial.

  4. 4

    Control Variable 2: Another factor kept constant. The mass (or surface area) of the magnesium ribbon must be the same for each trial.

Recap

  • A hypothesis is a testable scientific idea.
  • The independent variable (IV) is the one you change.
  • The dependent variable (DV) is the one you measure.
  • Control variables are all other factors you must keep constant for a fair test.
  • A prediction is a specific statement about what you expect to happen in your experiment.

Quick check

  1. In an experiment testing how different types of soil affect plant height, what is the independent variable?1 mark
  2. Why must control variables be kept constant?1 mark

2. Planning: Method, Safety, and Equipment

A good method is a clear, numbered, step-by-step set of instructions that another person could follow to repeat your experiment exactly. It should include the specific apparatus you will use and the quantities of substances. Before starting, you must perform a risk assessment. This involves identifying hazards (e.g., sulfuric acid, a Bunsen burner), assessing the risk (e.g., acid splashing in eyes causing blindness, burns from the hot flame), and stating the control measure to minimise that risk (e.g., wear safety goggles, tie back long hair). Choosing the right equipment is also vital. For example, use a measuring cylinder for approximate volumes but a burette or pipette for precise, accurate measurements. A gas syringe is better for collecting and measuring a gas than counting bubbles.

Key term

Risk Assessment: The process of identifying potential hazards, evaluating the risk of harm, and implementing control measures to minimise that risk.

Examiner insight

A good method is a logical sequence of instructions that is detailed enough for the experiment to be reproducible. Marks are often awarded for including specific quantities and naming correct apparatus.

Common pitfall

Simply stating 'wear safety goggles' without identifying the specific hazard it protects against, such as 'chemical splashes to the eyes'.

Fun fact

The globally recognized hazard symbols (GHS pictograms) were created by the United Nations to ensure safety information is understood across different languages and countries, preventing accidents in a globalised world.

Worked example 13 marks

A student is planning to heat a solution of copper sulfate in a beaker using a Bunsen burner. Complete a risk assessment for this procedure by identifying one hazard, the associated risk, and a suitable precaution.

  1. 1

    Hazard: Hot beaker and tripod stand after heating.

  2. 2

    Risk: Touching the hot apparatus could cause skin burns.

  3. 3

    Precaution / Control Measure: Allow the apparatus to cool down before moving it, or use heat-proof mats and tongs.

Worked example 21 mark

You need to measure exactly 25.0 cm³ of sodium hydroxide solution. Which single piece of apparatus is most suitable?

  1. 1

    A measuring cylinder has a high uncertainty and is not suitable for 'exact' measurements.

  2. 2

    A burette can deliver an exact volume, but a pipette is designed to deliver a specific, fixed volume.

  3. 3

    The most suitable piece of apparatus is a 25.0 cm³ volumetric pipette, as it is calibrated to deliver that specific volume very accurately.

Recap

  • A method should be a series of clear, numbered steps.
  • A risk assessment identifies the hazard, risk, and control measure.
  • Always wear safety goggles when working with chemicals, heat, or glassware under pressure.
  • Select apparatus appropriate for the required level of accuracy and precision.
  • Common hazards include corrosive chemicals, flammable substances, and hot equipment.

Quick check

  1. What is the name for the international symbols used to identify chemical hazards?1 mark

3. Collecting Accurate and Reliable Data

When carrying out your experiment, your goal is to collect high-quality data. This means the data should be accurate, precise, and reliable. Accuracy is how close a measurement is to the true value. You can improve accuracy by using correctly calibrated instruments and avoiding errors like parallax error (reading a scale from an angle). Precision is how close repeated measurements are to each other, which depends on the instrument's scale (e.g., a ruler with mm markings is more precise than one with only cm markings). Reliability is about consistency. To make your results reliable, you should repeat your readings at least three times and then calculate a mean (average). This process also helps you to spot and deal with anomalous results – readings that don't fit the pattern and can be excluded from the mean.

Mean = Sum of readings / Number of readings

Key term

Reliability: The extent to which an investigation or measurement yields the same results on repeated trials, often improved by taking repeats and calculating a mean.

Examiner insight

Students must explicitly state *why* repeats are taken – to identify anomalies and to calculate a more reliable mean. Simply saying 'to make it more reliable' may not be enough for full marks.

Common pitfall

Using the words 'accurate' and 'precise' interchangeably. A clock that is 10 minutes fast is precise if it ticks every second correctly, but it is not accurate.

Worked example 13 marks

A student measures the time taken for a reaction to finish. They repeat the experiment four times and get the following results: 45.2 s, 44.9 s, 51.3 s, 45.5 s. Calculate the mean time for the reaction. Show your working.

  1. 1

    Step 1: Identify any anomalous results. The readings 45.2 s, 44.9 s, and 45.5 s are all close together. The reading 51.3 s is much higher and does not fit the pattern. This is an anomaly.

  2. 2

    Step 2: State that the anomalous result will be ignored in the calculation of the mean. 'The result 51.3 s will be excluded as it is an anomaly.'

  3. 3

    Step 3: Calculate the mean of the remaining, reliable results. Mean = (45.2 + 44.9 + 45.5) / 3.

  4. 4

    Step 4: Complete the calculation and give the answer to an appropriate number of decimal places. Mean = 135.6 / 3 = 45.2 s.

Recap

  • Accuracy is how close a measurement is to the true value.
  • Precision is determined by the fineness of the scale on the measuring instrument.
  • Reliability is achieved by repeating measurements to ensure consistency.
  • Repeat readings allow you to calculate a mean and identify anomalies.
  • Anomalies are results that do not fit the pattern and should be excluded from mean calculations.

Quick check

  1. What is the main reason for repeating an experiment and calculating a mean?1 mark
  2. How can you avoid parallax error when reading a measuring cylinder?1 mark

4. Processing and Presenting Data

Once you have collected your data, you need to present it clearly. The best way to do this is in a results table. A good table has clear headings at the top of each column, includes the correct units in the headings (not in the body of the table), and has a border drawn with a ruler. The independent variable goes in the first column, and the dependent variable in the subsequent columns. After tabulating your data, you often need to draw a graph to visualise the relationship between your variables. Remember the acronym SLAP: Scale (use a sensible scale that covers at least half the graph paper), Line (draw a single, smooth line or curve of best fit), Axes (label both axes with the quantity and units, with the IV on the x-axis and DV on the y-axis), and Points (plot your points accurately using a small 'x' or a point in a circle). A line of best fit shows the trend in the data and helps you spot anomalies, which are points far away from the line.

Key term

Line of Best Fit: A line drawn on a graph that shows the general trend of the data, passing as close as possible to all the data points.

Examiner insight

Marks for graphs are highly specific and easy to gain or lose. Examiners check for correct axis labels with units, sensible scales that use over half the grid, accurately plotted points, and a single, smooth line of best fit.

Common pitfall

Forgetting to include units in table headings and on graph axes, or drawing a 'dot-to-dot' graph instead of a line of best fit.

Worked example 12 marks

A student recorded the temperature of water as it cooled over 10 minutes. The time was recorded in minutes (min) and the temperature in degrees Celsius (°C). Draw a suitable results table for their data.

  1. 1

    Step 1: Draw a box with columns and rows for the data.

  2. 2

    Step 2: Write the heading for the first column, which is the independent variable: 'Time / min'.

  3. 3

    Step 3: Write the heading for the second column, which is the dependent variable: 'Temperature / °C'.

  4. 4

    Step 4: Ensure the units are only in the headings, not next to each number in the table. The table is now ready for the data to be entered.

Worked example 21 mark

A graph is plotted for an enzyme experiment. The x-axis is labelled 'Temperature / °C' and the y-axis is labelled 'Rate of reaction / s⁻¹'. A point is plotted at (30, 0.5) but the line of best fit passes through (30, 0.8). What term is used to describe the plotted point?

  1. 1

    The point (30, 0.5) is far from the trend shown by the other data, which is represented by the line of best fit.

  2. 2

    A data point that does not fit the general pattern is called an anomalous result or an anomaly.

Recap

  • Results tables must have ruled lines, clear headings, and units in the headings only.
  • The independent variable (IV) goes in the first column of a table and on the x-axis of a graph.
  • The dependent variable (DV) goes in the other columns of a table and on the y-axis of a graph.
  • When drawing a graph, remember SLAP: Scale, Line, Axes, Points.
  • Do not join the dots on a graph; draw a single, smooth line or curve of best fit.

Quick check

  1. Which variable should be plotted on the x-axis of a graph?1 mark
  2. Where should the units be placed in a results table?1 mark

5. Drawing Conclusions and Evaluation

After analysing your data, you must draw a conclusion. A conclusion is a short summary that states what you have found. It should link the independent and dependent variables and describe the relationship or trend shown in your graph or table (e.g., 'As the temperature increases, the rate of reaction increases'). You must support your conclusion with evidence by quoting data. For example, '...for instance, at 20°C the rate was 10 cm³/s, but at 40°C the rate increased to 22 cm³/s'. Finally, you must evaluate your experiment. This means identifying limitations or sources of error in your method (e.g., 'It was difficult to judge the exact moment the reaction stopped') and suggesting specific, realistic improvements (e.g., 'Use a colorimeter to measure the colour change more objectively'). A good evaluation explains *how* the improvement would lead to more accurate or reliable data.

Key term

Evaluation: A critical assessment of an experimental method, identifying its limitations and proposing specific, practical improvements.

Examiner insight

A top-level evaluation goes beyond 'do more repeats' and suggests specific improvements to the procedure that would reduce errors and increase the accuracy or reliability of the data, explaining *how* the improvement works.

Common pitfall

Suggesting vague or unrealistic improvements like 'use better equipment' or 'be more careful'. Improvements must be specific, such as 'use a digital thermometer for more precise temperature readings'.

Worked example 12 marks

A student investigates the effect of light intensity on the rate of photosynthesis. Their graph shows a positive correlation. Write a conclusion for this experiment, using the data that at 20 units of light the rate was 15 bubbles/min, and at 80 units of light the rate was 55 bubbles/min.

  1. 1

    Step 1: State the relationship between the variables. 'My results show that as the light intensity increases, the rate of photosynthesis also increases.'

  2. 2

    Step 2: Support this statement by quoting data from the experiment. 'For example, at a light intensity of 20 units the rate was 15 bubbles/min, but when the intensity was increased to 80 units, the rate rose to 55 bubbles/min.'

  3. 3

    Step 3: (Optional extension) Briefly link to scientific knowledge. 'This is because light provides the energy for photosynthesis.'

Worked example 22 marks

In an experiment measuring the time it takes for a cross to disappear in a reaction that produces a precipitate, a student identifies a limitation: 'It was hard to see the cross'. Suggest one improvement for this.

  1. 1

    Limitation: The judgement of when the cross disappears is subjective and varies between people.

  2. 2

    Improvement: To make the measurement more objective and accurate, place a light sensor (connected to a datalogger) under the beaker. The experiment is stopped when the light reading falls to a specific, pre-determined value. This removes human reaction time and judgement error.

Recap

  • A conclusion must describe the trend or pattern in your results.
  • Always use data from your table or graph to support your conclusion.
  • An evaluation identifies weaknesses or limitations in your experimental method.
  • For every limitation, suggest a specific and practical improvement.
  • Explain how your suggested improvement would lead to more accurate or reliable results.

Quick check

  1. What is the most important thing to include in a conclusion, apart from the trend?1 mark
  2. Is 'do the experiment again' a good evaluation point? Why or why not?1 mark

End-of-chapter exercise

Test yourself on the whole chapter. Work through these before moving on.

  1. A scientist is investigating whether a new fertiliser, 'Gro-Fast', affects the mass of tomatoes produced by a plant. State the independent variable, the dependent variable, and two control variables for this investigation.4 marks
  2. Explain the difference between accuracy and precision in the context of a scientific measurement.2 marks
  3. A student obtains the following repeat measurements for the volume of gas produced in a reaction: 34.5 cm³, 34.8 cm³, 39.1 cm³, 35.0 cm³. Calculate the mean volume of gas produced, justifying your method.3 marks
  4. Describe the key safety precautions you would take when investigating the reaction between a reactive metal (like sodium) and water. For each precaution, state the hazard it protects against.4 marks
  5. You are asked to plot a graph of your results. State four key features of a good scientific graph.4 marks
  6. A student concludes from an experiment: 'The higher the temperature, the faster the reaction'. How could they improve this conclusion to gain more marks?2 marks
  7. In an experiment measuring the extension of a spring, a student notices the ruler is slightly worn at the zero mark. What type of error would this introduce, and how could it be minimised without replacing the ruler?2 marks
  8. Plan a method to investigate how the surface area of a solid reactant affects the rate of a chemical reaction. Your plan should allow you to collect valid data.6 marks
  9. A student uses a stopwatch to time a reaction that takes about 15 seconds. They identify human reaction time as a major source of error. Suggest a specific improvement to the method that would reduce the impact of this error, and explain how it helps.3 marks
  10. Evaluate the use of a 2D diagram to represent the 3D structure of a chemical molecule. State one strength and one significant limitation.2 marks

Go deeper

Practise and revise with member-only material for this chapter.

Free notes are just the start.

Unlock every Workbook and Chapter at a Glance, and generate your own worksheets and predicted papers.

Explore plans

Related chapters